Scheda libro
Non-Fiction
Vincent Lavoie

L'affaire Capa

Processo a un'icona

  • ISBN: 978-88-6010-226-3
  • Year: 2019
  • Pages: 167
  • Size: 15,5 x 23 cm
  • Illustrations: 65 b/w
  • Language: Italian
  • Price: 23,00 €

In 1937, Spain was in the midst of a devastating civil war. In July, a special report in Life magazine gave a tragic account of the lives cut short in one year of combat. The article was accompanied by Robert Capa’s The Falling Soldier, a photograph destined to become an icon of republican heroism known around the world. The image places viewers in the very moment of the death of a soldier struck in the face by enemy fire. But was that really what happened? As we know, at the height of a conflict so ideologically radicalized, the gaze of war correspondents is necessarily biased.

Beginning in the 70s, commentators on this image began to express suspicion and increasing doubt about its veracity; some even claimed that it was deliberately staged. Does that mean that the image that gave birth to the myth of the war photojournalist diving into the fray with the Leica around his neck is false? Such questions triggered a full-blown “Capa affair”, in which photojournalism was put on trial in episodes, with accusers and defenders arguing heatedly about the place of the tragedy, the identity of the soldier and the sequence of the photographs. At the heart of the arguments advanced by both sides lies the question of authenticity, that sacred obligation of photojournalism.

With all the ingenuity of a detective, Vincent Lavoie assembles a mosaic of eye-witness testimonies, relevant documents and criminal findings, along with incongruities, falsified negatives and misleading diversions. In this way, he has produced a vivid, persuasive investigation of truthfulness in photography that retraces the steps of this momentous controversy. In these times of “fake news” and endless manipulation of images, Lavoie’s book proves to be startlingly relevant

  • About the author
  • Contents

Historian of photography, Vincent Lavoie teaches in the Department of Art History in the Université du Québec à Montréal (uqam) and directs Figura – Centre de recherche sur le texte et l’imaginaire. He has written Photojournalismes. Revoir les canons de l’image de presse (2010) and La Preuve par l’image (2017) as well as many articles published in collective works.

Introduzione 
Accusare le parole dell’immagine 
Il Miliziano colpito a morte sotto tre regimi di verità 
1. La parola dei testimoni 
Knightley e l’attestazione testimoniale 
Una vecchia gerarchia dei valori probatori 
Le affermazioni di Capa 
2. La risposta documentale 
La periferia di un’icona 
Il secondo Miliziano colpito a morte 
La prova documentale 
Il valore probatorio delle stampe a contatto 
La Valigia messicana, matrice di tutte le matrici 
3. Le perizie criminalistiche sull’immagine 
La visibilità del crimine 
Il Miliziano colpito a morte: una scena del crimine? 
La traccia invisibile 
Conclusioni: arringhe finali 
Behind the Photo: Robert Capa’s D-Day 
Il Miliziano colpito a morte, bis 
Una questione di autenticità